What Good Sci-Fi is Out There?

Sci-Fi movies have a long and checkered past. They run the gamut from such high concept films as 2001: A Space Odyssey to such dreck as Plan Nine from Outer Space. And in addition to quality these films vary by sub-genre. There are movies that concentrate on technology and how humans will adapt to it. This category includes such movies as I, Robot and The Martian. There are movies that are mostly about contacts with alien life of one form or another. This would include everything from War of the Worlds to Independence Day. Then there are movies that are basically monster movies like Alien and The Thing from Another World where the science fiction is just a vehicle to allow things to jump out at the protagonists from dark corners.
I will confess that I can enjoy almost any of these types of movies on any given day if given the chance. But it seems of late the quality of sci-fi is in decline. All kinds of money is being spent on special effects and the acting is really no worse than it’s been in the past. So what’s different?
First, I would say, is the quality of scripts. The words coming out of the characters mouths are getting less interesting. I have been assured that motion pictures are a visual medium in which dialogue is an ancillary dimension of the experience and entirely superfluous. That a good movie shows you not tells you. I disagree. Of course the visual is primary. But if the movie is about people then they need to talk to each other and if the dialogue is bad then the film is bad even if you blow up all the planets in the solar system in alphabetical order in vibrant Technicolor. Let me clarify one thing. I am not advocating for highly polished dramatic set pieces. Dialogue between a street dweller and a policeman can be good without breaking into Shakespeare. All I’m saying is the dialogue is either lame or non-existent in most sci-fi movies today.
Second, the majority of the protagonists are not particularly likeable. Once again let me qualify. I’m not saying I want the good guys to be boy scouts, far from it. But a flawed character can still be the character the audience identifies and empathizes with. As an example from detective fiction, think about Sam Spade. He’s cruel, selfish and violent. But there’s never any doubt whether we want him or his adversaries to come out on top. The characters now seem either evil or just ciphers.
And lastly, the stories that these movies are based on are usually not very substantial. Think of some of the great stories that have been written. Even restricting myself to one author, Heinlein, I could point out a dozen books and short stories that could be made into excellent films. Wouldn’t “The Moon is a Harsh Mistress” make a great movie? And how about “Farmer in the Sky”? And I think audiences would eat up “Have Spacesuit Will Travel.” The danger is that the studios would turn each movie into a franchise and we’d be subjected to hacks tacking sequels onto completed stories. I’ve heard “Starship Troopers” might be remade as a faithful interpretation of the book. That would be great. But I’m not holding my breath.
Now I’ve ranted against what I don’t like. Let me see if I can identify some that I do. Caveat, I haven’t gone out of my way looking for good sci-fi. But I’ve managed to bump into a lot that’s bad. And I’m leaving out all things Star Wars and Star Trek. I won’t even go there.
• “The Martian” was okay. Despite the fact that I despise Matt Damon he did a decent job and the story though far from brilliant was somewhat engaging and clever.
• The first installment of “The Matrix” was pretty good. Granted it’s almost twenty years old but being much older I will include it in recent.
• If I’m allowed to stretch apocalyptic films as science fiction I’ll point to the “Book of Eli.”
So that’s it. Maybe I’ve missed some. If anybody has any movies from the last twenty years that past muster, leave a comment. We can discuss.

7 thoughts on “What Good Sci-Fi is Out There?

  • July 6, 2017 at 4:27 pm

    This just barely makes it under the 20 year cutoff, but Dark City (1998) was very well done. It had excellent cinematography and very good dialog along with a rather unique plot.
    I recommend you see it if you haven’t.

    • July 6, 2017 at 8:40 pm

      Yes a good choice, Dave. I do remember renting that one a few years after it came out. A friend recommended it. He was right. It was original and good. Very atmospheric, claustrophobic.

      I was hoping some folks would add on some good recommendations like this. That’s the way to put together a comprehensive list (and spur healthy debate).


  • July 7, 2017 at 11:57 am

    Two more good movies: John Carter (2012). This movie flopped in the theaters, probably because they chose to title it “John Carter” instead of “John Carter of Mars” – so most fans didn’t recognize it as Science Fiction – I know I didn’t. It’s based on Edgar Rice Burroughs’ “Princess of Mars”. Had they called it that, I would have known it was Science Fiction. “John Carter” doesn’t mean anything more to the average person than “John Wick”.
    The movie is visually beautiful, absolutely beautiful. I cannot do it justice. See it in Blu Ray. The plot and character development are pretty good too but the cinematography and FX are spectacular.

    Edge of Tomorrow (2014) is a rather unique take on war and alien invasions. I cannot say I recall much of the dialog, but the FX were great and the plot kept me guessing. I saw it in spite of Tom Cruise (not a fan) but it was still a good movie.

    • July 7, 2017 at 1:05 pm

      Thanks for the recommendations. I’ll add them to my Netflix queue. I heard of John Carter but I was deterred by the reviews.

  • Pingback: What Good Sci-Fi is Out There? – Part 2 – Orion's Cold Fire

  • July 16, 2017 at 12:36 pm

    You can’t leave Blade Runner out though it is (my god!) 35 years old.

    • July 16, 2017 at 2:22 pm

      Fair enough. It is remarkable how well it holds up. And it provides Harrison Ford with the perfect vehicle. The noir setting allows him to hit his laconic sweet spot. A few good tough guy lines and lots of fists and bullets. But Rutger Hauer really steals that show. “Time to die.”


Leave a Reply to Tom Dulaney Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.