The ZMan wrote a very interesting post called, “No Easy Answers.” It’s an analysis of the consequences of large scale non-European immigration into the United States, its consequences and an opinion on the useful response that white Americans should have. I’ll critique the essential portions of the essay to show what I think is the situation. Note that I’ve cut and pasted several of his sentences together to save some space. His text is in bold face font.
“Given current immigration and fertility numbers, America will be a majority-minority country within a generation. The crisis of our age is not just how we respond to this reality, but how we come to accept it. The civic nationalists will move heaven and earth in order to avoid facing demographic reality. For the recently red-pilled, all of their efforts were based on the belief that the solution was simple. Just red-pill everyone and the problem is solved.”
I agree with this analysis and the characterization of the reactions of the civic nationalists and the newly woke dissident right.
“The possibility that liberal democracy inevitably leads to cultural suicide is unpleasant, so even the red-pilled look the other way. The fact is, another bit of that dreaded demographic reality is that what comes next cannot include the current system of governance. In a multicultural society, everyone’s primary loyalty is to their group. Liberal democracy assumes people are loyal to their narrow economic interests. In a majority-minority society, this cannot possibly work. What comes next for us is what we see in the Middle East. In every country, one group dominates the rest, imposing their idea of order on the society. Saddam controlled Iraq for his people. The Persians run Iran. The Muslims run Lebanon, where every hill and valley may as well be its own country. The rule in multi-cultural, multi-tribal societies, is that one tribe rules the rest. That’s our future. The question is which groups will come to dominate the rest and what sort of system will they impose in order to remain in charge.”
ZMan’s thesis is that in a majority-minority society the form of government will devolve into a rule by the strongest tribe. The implied condition is that the rule is enforced by the threat of military or street violence. His examples are middle-eastern dictatorships. I’m not convinced of this for a couple of reasons. One reason is the existence of places like Switzerland and Singapore where a multi-ethnic state exists in a reasonably peaceful coexistence. And secondly a case could be made that the immigration of the Irish and the Eastern and Southern Europeans during the late 19th and early 20th century was an analogous if not equivalent example of a majority-minority situation that while disrupting and modifying the United states, did not destroy the country. The American culture was attractive and strong enough to subsume the new immigrant populations and produce a changed but recognizable United States. The real difference this time is the degree to which there is a significant portion of the American people who are actively working to destroy the existing culture through anti-American and specifically anti-white activities and propaganda. It seems to me the focus of white Americans should be identifying the people and institutions actively working to destroy our people and work to destroy them instead. And the reason I think this will work is that recently there have been some successes. The Supreme Court case where the wedding baker was exonerated based on freedom of religion. The other recent Supreme Court decision that bears on this is the Ohio state law that allowed clearing the voting rolls of ineligible voters. These affirmations of the clear intent of constitutional safeguards will allow the United States to continue to function as the rational and enlightened sort of country it’s always been. And these rulings occurred even before Anthony Kennedy is replaced. Once he has been, I could see a conservative Supreme Court ending affirmative action. Now, the argument against this is that something like ending affirmative action will never be allowed to happen.
But that will be the test. If the ZMan is right then even if the whole white population is “woke,” nothing will be done to alleviate the anti-white activity. But if I’m right then with someone like Trump, a republican who’s actually on our side, we should make some headway and see some victories won. In the next part of this post I’ll try to think of concrete actions that need to be taken.