I just don’t feel the anger this week. Sure there are all kinds of outrages to get outraged about but I’m just feeling outraged out. I propose to talk about positive things. So extending the previous post about deplatforming, I’d like to consider how to select what alternative platforms the Right should develop for itself. Where to start? Two selection principles come to mind.
2) Likelihood of Success
Both of these criteria have their merits. In fact I think that each is the best criterion for a different participant audience. The critical platforms, like on-line financing or large corporate entities like a large social media network or retail commercial entity, are projects that require the cooperation of large groups for funding and support. In this way resources and time is available to nurture a difficult project that is sorely needed but not easy to achieve. So these are projects that should be supported by collective action. On the other hand, personal goals should be the ones that have a high likelihood of succeeding. And in addition to a high likelihood of success they should also be reasonably profitable in whatever connotation that can have. So for instance a business venture that will earn a good income or a hobby that will provide a goodly amount of satisfaction those would qualify as profitable endeavors. In this way it fits the resources and enthusiasm of the small time operator. It will be seen as a positive endeavor and not a drain on the individual.
And this is how I address my place in the greater scheme of things. If someone who has more resources and/or energy is endeavoring to build some ambitious platform or entity that will benefit the larger community, I support it with my small resources and by publicizing it. For my own projects they are more modest. I will build a website and try to provide an environment where like-minded individuals can communicate and socialize without the endless trolling and official censure of the Facebooks and Twitters.
I put up the link for a Directory Right Wing Businesses to encourage other folks to pass along info on people on our side trying to make a go of it. So far that has been fairly inactive but time will tell if the readers get more enthusiastic as things move forward.
Of course, at some point much more will have to be done. I think it is overly optimistic to think the federal government will be successful in forcing the social media companies to play fair. I think it will be the profit motive that draws some fairly larger groups forward to provide the equivalent of Stripe, PayPal and the crowdfunding companies for those of us on the Right who are being threatened with deplatforming. Whether that will happen in months or years depends on how the Left presses forward with their purge. If they go too far it will definitely produce a market for alternatives.
So that’s my current thought on making our own stuff. Agree, disagree, any comments?
Who survives the great purge on Twitter and Facebook and YouTube and who does not? It’s an interesting question. If being banished from YouTube is the end of your career then I guess the ranks will be significantly thinned next year. Apparently, the powers that be want to go this way. It will be interesting to see if anyone steps into the breech with a platform that functions enough like YouTube to provide a revenue stream to those dispossessed from the mainstream sites. As demonstrated by the YouTube shooter, some people can make a living (of some sort) from YouTube popularity alone. I myself, not having a presence on Facebook, Twitter or YouTube, am currently outside the influence of the conventional social media networks. But there are quite a few people who earn a living off of the advertising that a YouTube site generates. Will these people simply disappear or will they attempt to self-monetize via paid subscriptions or some other mechanism? This is a pretty important question. People talk a lot about building new platforms for the right but actually getting one up and running is much easier said than done. Being forced to do it will be a painful and difficult ordeal. But if anyone does make the transition it will be an important beachhead that will provide that person a significant advantage. If he can make the service available to others it will be a virtual monopoly since I doubt a second conservative social media entrepreneur will spring up to challenge it.
Or maybe YouTube once put outside the reach of conservatives will be bypassed as a concept. After all, podcasts and website-based subscriptions are easy enough to do. No one has to use the YouTube model. Personally, I like the idea of a podcast type arrangement. I don’t currently do anything behind a paywall but I actually think it’s the arrangement that makes the most sense. If you have something of value people will be willing to pay something for it. The negotiations will of course be how much. I have in the past subscribed to a few of these. But I am very interested to see which way all this goes. In some ways, it seems the folks at YouTube and Twitter may be making a big mistake. If they do force the Right to become self-sufficient on their own platforms it might actually strengthen them and remove the leverage the Left currently has and uses against the Right to great effect.
I really feel the Right Wing has been very ineffective up until now exploiting the power of the internet commercially. It’s shocking how little has been done to challenge the media monopoly the old media enjoys even over the internet. Basically, a handful of sites make up the bulk of right wing opinion. Hopefully this will improve in the next few years and we can hope to see less reliance on Fox News and Drudge. Even Real Clear Politics seems to have way too much left wing editorial positioning and not enough interesting voices from the Right. American Greatness is good but voices from even farther to the Right should be included to capture the range of ideas that need to be considered.
With all the items in the news about Silicon Valley de-platforming anyone that doesn’t parrot the Progressive Talking Points it is becoming crystal clear that we are no longer one nation, indivisible. We are demonstrably two nations. And what is also becoming clear is that we don’t like each other at all. Of course most of us don’t react the way the YouTube shooter reacted to her demonetization. But she was a vegan so that may be an extenuating circumstance. Regardless, we are seeing a sea change in the way Americans react to each other. And nothing makes this point more than who we elected President. And Trump was a direct result of Obama. Obama was the moment when the Left took off the mask and went for broke. The Democrats used up all their political capital to get Obamacare over the finish line. It cost them the House and the Senate and a bunch of state legislatures and governorships. And once he lost the legislative option he started using Executive Orders and the Justice Department to start punishing the country for rejecting his agenda. He supported BLM thuggery and punished the police any chance he got.
So now it’s our turn. President Trump is a gigantic thumb in the eye to all the Obama Administration personnel hanging onto their executive branch jobs. He cancels all the programs they favor and prunes away the excess jobs that they dole out to their various sychophants. And he always adds insult to injury. He mocks them on Twitter and names names. He continues to provide help to the normal people. He goes after the illegal immigrants and the criminals and he calls them names while doing it. It’s like having George Costanza as President. Spite is almost the highest policy imperative there is.
And where does this all go? Damned if I know. I expect the program to continue as long as Trump is President. I hope he makes a second term. Eight years with him in charge may be enough to break down the Deep State. And if he manages to tutor Pence or some other hopeful republican in the nuances of Trumpian politics maybe we can get a total of sixteen years under a non-leftist regime. And that should be enough to find out if there are enough Americans left in America to take back the country from the lunatics. I’m pretty sure it’s a long shot. We’ve never been able to string together enough luck to do more than slow down the long march down the slippery slope to Hell but at least we have a shot.
But, enough daydreaming. Let’s look at what we have to look forward to in the next couple of years. Google and Facebook and Microsoft and Amazon and all the other thought-police are going to demonetize anyone they don’t like (which is us) and try to completely de-platform the right wing. And for the most part they will succeed. Will the right-wing manage to build its own platforms? Maybe. Will it happen smoothly? No. But I have a feeling that the Silicon Valley Grandees will have plenty of their own problems. President Trump doesn’t particularly like them. And he has a funny way of making trouble for the folks he doesn’t like. So I think it will be an interesting world we’ll live in and I think it’ll be bumpy but I think we are going to see the landscape begin to tilt in our direction. Hopefully I don’t sound too optimistic but I think those who are discouraged should be patient. Do your part. Support the stuff you like and support Trump. He’s our last best hope.
Vox and the ZMan both look at this situation and address different aspects. Vox says if you don’t build your own platforms you will be destroyed. Zman sees the current situation as a Public Utility, no different from the electric company discriminating against its customers.
Both good and valid points. But I think Vox is speaking to right now and Zman is pointing out something for the justice department to look into. As someone who use Google for various services it brings home the point that having your own support system and not depending on liberals is a good idea. But a hard one to achieve.