I’m doing this review on a whim. I just saw this movie for the first time since I saw it on Million Dollar Movie probably about fifty years ago and what I could remember of it even as a kid was that it seemed slightly hammy. In retrospect it’s a lot hammy. Instead of the Ringling Brothers’ Barnum and Bailey Circus; “The Greatest Show Earth,” we’re watching the Whirling and Borman Brothers Circus; “The Biggest Show on Earth.” Remarkable creativity there.
But Hank Whirling (played by Victor Mature) has split up with the Borman brothers and taken his own circus on the road. But he needs money so he goes to the local bank and gets a loan but in exchange for the money he has to take along two bank employees; Randy Sherman (played by Red Buttons) and Helen Harrison (played by Rhonda Fleming). Helen is a publicist who is supposed to help make the circus’s tour successful (and end up as the love interest for Hank). Red Buttons is there to be Red Buttons and annoy everyone. Vincent Price is the circus master Hans Hagenfeld. Gilbert Roland is the high wire star Zach Colino. Peter Lorre is an obese decrepit version of himself as an alcoholic clown named Skeeter. David Nelson is Tommy Gordon, the aerialist and saboteur. And Howard McNear is Mr. Lomax, the bank employee sent to foreclose on the circus when Red Buttons refuses.
Forget the plot. It has to do with the Borman Brothers sabotaging the circus. But it’s too dumb to care about. What you have here is a collection of B-movie actors strung together to make a cinemascope spectacle involving elephants and lions. And you know this from the get-go. Anything with Red Buttons in it will be nothing else. And Victor Mature and Vincent Price are exhibits B and C. Look, they didn’t even get Ricky Nelson, the popular Nelson son. Instead, they got his brother David, the one who couldn’t sing. And the only thing Howard McNear is remembered for is playing the oddly disturbing Floyd the Barber character from the Andy Griffith Show.
So, I’m watching this clunker. Everything about it is hackneyed and telegraphed. But there’s a lion act in it and it’s really fun to watch. And there’s a clown sequence and it’s mildly amusing. And there are some scenes with the elephants and suddenly I’m remembering how I used to like seeing the elephants at the circus. And there are some girls dancing around in harem outfits and that’s not so bad. And even Victor Mature and Vincent Price hamming it up isn’t so bad.
And before you know it, I find myself enjoying this awful movie. By the end when they introduce Steve Allen as himself providing network tv as a lifeline to save the circus during a NYC subway strike, I find myself completely forgiving all the schmaltz. I even forgive the scene where the tightrope walker manages to cross over Niagara Falls to restore his lost courage and honor.
And of course, by the end of the movie there are at least two incipient marriages. Victor Mature will marry Rhonda Fleming and Red Buttons will marry the sister of Mature’s character (whoever the hell she was). All they left out was bloated Peter Lorre marrying one of the elephants.
So, I can’t recommend this movie on its merits. It has none. But if you’re nostalgic for the circus, watch this and pretend the Ringling Bros. circus still exists. The lion scene is really fun.