5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ed Brault
Ed Brault
3 months ago

After four years at Minot, ND and thirty-six in Northern NY and Vermont, I can relate.

Tregonsee314
Tregonsee314
3 months ago
Reply to  Ed Brault

Indeed even growing up on the Connecticut shoreline (which has wimpy winters in comparison with say Minot) the meaning was clear. Attending College in Worcester MA made the meaning FAR more obvious.

Tregonsee314
Tregonsee314
3 months ago

This is a beautiful Christmas Carol. It was elegantly set by Gustav Holst (tune Cranham https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_the_Bleak_Midwinter). I have heard said he heard Ms. Rosetti recite the poem at a reading and, afterwards, asked (and nearly begged) her to let him set it to music. The poem has 5 verses but the traditional carol uses only V 1,2,4, and 5 due to content issues in V 3 (go look you won’t be singing V 3 at most churches 🙂 as it directly references Mary feeding Jesus in the only way you could in 1st century Judea). There is also a Benjamin… Read more »