So, everybody’s been talking about Trump’s let’s-make-a-deal ideas about Greenland and Canada. I’ll leave the Panama Canal out of this because that’s more of a strategic situation. But Canada and Greenland are a very interesting opportunity. All of that northern real estate really makes a lot of sense if the world really is warming, for whatever reason. Northern Canada and even Greenland might be the new North American breadbasket. And the mineral wealth of the north is currently incalculably large.
Now some Canadians have been outraged at Trump’s talk about a 51st state. One Canadian legislator took a shot back and said that California, Oregon and Washington would be better off leaving the US and becoming a part of Canada. Well, that has its advantages for both sides. And it inspired me to think about the US and Canada getting together and doing some real horse-trading that would better align the red and blue parts of Anglo-America into two more homogeneous groupings. Basically, I imagined Canada adding the American Northeast, part of the Great Lakes States and the West Coast while America gets the Rocky Mountain, Plains and Arctic provinces and territories from Canada. Oh, and we paint Greenland red too.
Think of it. No more wrangling every four years during the elections. All of the blue states and the blue provinces together feeling smug and virtuous. While the red states and provinces will be rid of them and free to enjoy life on our own terms without their constant complaining, lunacy and hypocrisy.
Basically, we would lose about a third of our population but double the size of the country. They would more than triple their population while losing about a third of the area that was Canada. But there would be so much more temperate climate than in old Canada that I can’t imagine they’d complain much about it. One slight problem, their territory would no longer be one contiguous area. There would be East Coast Wokistan and West Coast Wokistan but what’s a few plane flights between friends? Plus, they’re bound to start a feud between themselves and that will just give them an excuse to break into two pieces anyway.
So, there it is. A big beautiful deal just waiting to be brokered by the world’s biggest wheeler-dealer. Come on make it happen.
| Region | Population | Area (square miles) |
| Current United States of America | 335,073,176 | 3,796,676 |
| Current Canada | 41,288,599 | 3,855,103 |
| Current Greenland | 56,583 | 836,330 |
| New and Improved USA | 233,003,747 | 6,290,802 |
| Whatever is Left Over | 143,414,611 | 2,197,307 |
Below is an ersatz map of what the two new countries would look like.
Below this is the details of the area and populations of the component states and provinces that I used for the calculations above.
| Current Regions | ||
| Region | Population | Area (square miles) |
| Alabama | 5,157,699 | 52,420 |
| Alaska | 740,133 | 665,384 |
| Arizona | 7,582,384 | 113,990 |
| Arkansas | 3,088,354 | 53,179 |
| Colorado | 5,957,493 | 104,094 |
| Delaware | 1,051,917 | 2,489 |
| District of Columbia | 702,250 | 68 |
| Florida | 23,372,215 | 65,758 |
| Georgia | 11,180,878 | 59,425 |
| Hawaii | 1,446,146 | 10,932 |
| Idaho | 2,001,619 | 83,569 |
| Indiana | 6,924,275 | 36,420 |
| Iowa | 3,241,488 | 56,273 |
| Kansas | 2,970,606 | 82,278 |
| Kentucky | 4,588,372 | 40,408 |
| Louisiana | 4,597,740 | 52,378 |
| Maryland | 6,263,220 | 12,406 |
| Michigan | 10,140,459 | 96,714 |
| Mississippi | 2,943,045 | 48,432 |
| Missouri | 6,245,466 | 69,707 |
| Montana | 1,137,233 | 147,040 |
| Nebraska | 2,005,465 | 77,348 |
| Nevada | 3,267,467 | 110,572 |
| New Mexico | 2,130,256 | 121,590 |
| North Carolina | 11,046,024 | 53,819 |
| North Dakota | 796,568 | 70,698 |
| Ohio | 11,883,304 | 44,826 |
| Oklahoma | 4,095,393 | 69,899 |
| Pennsylvania | 13,078,751 | 46,054 |
| South Carolina | 5,478,831 | 32,020 |
| South Dakota | 924,669 | 77,116 |
| Tennessee | 7,227,750 | 42,144 |
| Texas | 31,290,831 | 268,596 |
| Utah | 3,503,613 | 84,897 |
| Virginia | 8,811,195 | 42,775 |
| West Virginia | 1,769,979 | 24,230 |
| Wisconsin | 5,960,975 | 65,496 |
| Wyoming | 587,618 | 97,813 |
| Manitoba | 1,494,301 | 250,116 |
| Saskatchewan | 1,239,865 | 251,366 |
| Alberta | 4,888,723 | 255,541 |
| Northwest Territories | 44,731 | 519,734 |
| Yukon | 46,704 | 186,272 |
| Nunavut | 41,159 | 808,185 |
| Greenland | 56,583 | 836,330 |
| New and Improved USA | 233,003,747 | 6,290,802 |
| California | 39,431,263 | 163,695 |
| Connecticut | 3,675,069 | 5,543 |
| Illinois | 12,710,158 | 57,914 |
| Maine | 1,405,012 | 35,380 |
| Massachusetts | 7,136,171 | 10,554 |
| Minnesota | 5,793,151 | 86,936 |
| New Hampshire | 1,409,032 | 9,349 |
| New Jersey | 9,500,851 | 8,723 |
| New York | 19,867,248 | 54,555 |
| Oregon | 4,272,371 | 98,379 |
| Rhode Island | 1,112,308 | 1,545 |
| Vermont | 648,493 | 9,616 |
| Washington | 7,958,180 | 71,298 |
| Ontario | 16,124,116 | 415,598 |
| Quebec | 9,056,044 | 595,391 |
| Nova Scotia | 1,076,374 | 21,345 |
| New Brunswick | 854,355 | 28,150 |
| British Columbia | 5,698,430 | 364,764 |
| Prince Edward Island | 178,550 | 2,185 |
| Newfoundland and Labrador | 545,247 | 156,453 |
| Whatever is Left Over | 143,414,611 | 2,197,307 |

One problem. We NEED those left coast ports. We need the naval bases and shipping ports. Without those ports and bases, the Pacific becomes a Chinese lake. If Hawaii is not allowed to go blue, they may do a secret deal with China. Japan and Taiwan would fall under Chinese control. So would Guam and the Philippines. Australia would be cut off and may become a Chinese satrapy. Trade routes, now kept open by the US Navy, would be subject to Chinese whims. They could choke us off from raw materials and play hell with US food and other exports.… Read more »
Fine, we’ll connect Arizona to the Pacific with a corridor at San Diego. But unless we want to bother emptying out California I say let the Leftists keep LaLa Land.
I think it is offensive to assume Canadians would be blithely willing to give up their history and identity to become a part of the United States. It is ironic that President Trump ran on a patriotic campaign of Make America Great Again, but other Americans think that Canadians do not have the same patriotic feelings about their country even though the government had been usurped by the foul socialist left. Hopefully, Pierre Poilievre will make great strides in Making Canada Great Again.
Linn, you sound like a Canadian patriot and I applaud your spirit. This thought experiment was sparked by a Canadian liberal politician who took umbrage at Trump talking about Canada as a 51st state. What she proposed was that California, Oregon and Washington states should join Canada. I took her up on her proposal and expanded it to swapping out the “blue” and “red” areas of each country to create two polarized new countries. Now maybe Canadians of either political persuasion haven’t reached the point where they’d like to split their country into two nations. But right-wing Americans sure have.… Read more »
Don’t sweat Trump’s rhetoric on taking Canada or Greemland by force. He’s just stirring the leftist pot to see what surfaces. While the natural resources of Canada are attractive, we alreay get them at wholesale prices from you. No mosquitos, blackflies or lovesick muskox to deal with. Canada has gotten away with being a third rate military power by riding sidesaddle on the US defense budget. When you lay right next to a 900 pound gorilla, not many will poke you. Any Chinese fleet aimed at Canada would be turned back by a mountie in a rowboat with a STOP… Read more »
Thank both of you for the comments; I appreciate them. I kind of figured that Trump was “poking the bear”, but I was a little dismayed that so many took him seriously.
Linn, there’s a lot of rhetoric that gets thrown around. And Trump talks trash a lot. But the thing that is real is the dissatisfaction almost everywhere with the status quo that Biden and Newsom and Trudeau and Macron and most of the leaders who supposedly represented the globalist elite have been responsible for. I think things will change
My hope also.
That is good.