“The America of my time line is a laboratory example of what can happen to democracies, what has eventually happened to all perfect democracies throughout all histories. A perfect democracy, a ‘warm body’ democracy in which every adult may vote and all votes count equally, has no internal feedback for self-correction. It depends solely on the wisdom and self-restraint of citizens… which is opposed by the folly and lack of self-restraint of other citizens. What is supposed to happen in a democracy is that each sovereign citizen will always vote in the public interest for the safety and welfare of all. But what does happen is that he votes his own self-interest as he sees it… which for the majority translates as ‘Bread and Circuses.’
‘Bread and Circuses’ is the cancer of democracy, the fatal disease for which there is no cure. Democracy often works beautifully at first. But once a state extends the franchise to every warm body, be he producer or parasite, that day marks the beginning of the end of the state. For when the plebs discover that they can vote themselves bread and circuses without limit and that the productive members of the body politic cannot stop them, they will do so, until the state bleeds to death, or in its weakened condition the state succumbs to an invader—the barbarians enter Rome.”― Robert A. Heinlein
Tag: democracy
A Pocket Full of Miracles
For a thousand years from roughly 500 BC to 500 AD the most dynamic civilization on the planet was the Greco-Roman world. This consisted of a number of Indo-European speaking pastoral tribes who had earlier invaded southeastern Europe and disrupting the existing Mediterranean civilization there, borrowed heavily from their predecessors and founded city states in Italy, Asia Minor and the Balkans while competing with the more civilized Phoenicians and struggling to resist even less civilized Indo-European tribes like the Celts who periodically invaded from the north. Two of these cities; first Athens in Hellas and then Rome in Italy, stumbled upon the dynamism that comes when some measure of freedom from oppression is codified into a government.
In both cases the limited form of democracy unleashed a power that dominated its neighbors for an appreciable time. Eventually in both cases this freedom decayed and was replaced by autocracy.
A little more than a thousand years after the remnants of the Greco-Roman civilization collapsed the English resurrected a different but similar form of government. And the English colonies around the world have continued and adapted this form of government including the former colonies that became the United States of America. A case can be made that the last four hundred years have represented the practical extent of this experiment in democracy. And like the Athenians before them the American and the British have tried to force their vassal states to emulate their form of government, so that today the number of democracies in the world is impressive, unless you look too closely.
But four hundred years is a long time. Athens maintained democracy for most of one hundred and eighty years and theoretically the Roman republic hadn’t devolved into a dictatorship for almost five hundred years. But truly the last century of the Roman republic was a series of dictators vying to stay in power and unleashing endless wars on the state.
So, four hundred years is a pretty good run. But the current Anglo-American project is showing many of the warning signs of an exhausted civilization. And probably the most damning is the plutocrats trying to eliminate the middle-class and replace them with serfs. Even back in 4th century Athens, Aristotle knew that only with a numerous middle-class can a free state maintain itself. Well, we are quickly devolving into the condition that the Roman plebians found themselves in the first century BC. Their farms were bought up by the rich who used slave labor to outcompete the small farmers and left them forced to enlist in the army just to keep from starving.
Our predicament is even worse. The plutocrats don’t need us at all, not even as cannon fodder. All they want us to do is disappear. So that leaves us with Donald Trump. He says he wants to make us great again. He’ll have to answer two questions:
- Is it too late to get an honest election?
- Is it too late to restore the middle class?
Of course, if the first answer is no then the second answer is no by default. I am hoping he can pull it off. Getting a fair election is a long shot. But there’s no reason to hope against it. Restoring prosperity is a larger and more complicated story. And finally, if he manages to get some things done, the next question is can he recruit honest men to succeed him and keep the effort going. Because, let’s face it, there is a generation of work to even begin to fix our problems. It’ll take a whole pocket full of miracles.
One thing that the Athenians had over us is honest comic poets. Aristophanes openly mocked the failures and foibles of the leaders of his country. All we have is Saturday Night Live and the late-night show hosts. And they’re all in the bag for the Democrats. And on top of everything else they’re not even funny. Well, we have this guy.
Roe V. Wade Overturned. Finally.
Supreme Court OVERTURNS Roe v. Wade, Casey With Dobbs Decision
Finally. It took fifty years but it’s happened. A half century of lies and five men and women finally told the truth. The Constitution of the United States does not guarantee the right of a woman to terminate the life of her unborn child. Now the various states will decide what their people want. Places like California will double down and legalize infanticide. Others will ban abortion completely. But at least it will be the choice of the citizens of those states.
It’s hard to overstate the importance of this event. This was the Holy Grail of conservative objectives. This was a wrong that needed to be righted in the minds of millions of people for half a century. This gives hope to all the aspirations that we’ve been told were impossible to fix for all these years. Now we’ll find out just how popular abortion really is. I’m betting that a lot of people will be surprised at how ambivalent women actually are about the supposed benefits of being allowed to end the life of an unborn child.
Now we step into a new and different world. Things that have gone unsaid for decades will be uttered and the will of the people will be revealed in all its conflicted reality.
Bring it on, bring it on, bring it on.
The Paradox of Western Civilization
To anybody who came of age in America before, let’s say 1990, it’s always maddening to hear the views of Millennials on the subject of Western History. They are completely convinced that the world would have been a paradise if only the evil Europeans hadn’t interfered with all the good people everywhere else. So, because the settlers dispossessed the Indians and used slave labor for agriculture and used the advanced weapons and tactics that they invented to conquer the whole world this must mean that the Europeans were morally inferior to the peoples they defeated. The fact that history and archeology show that humans everywhere and at all times have waged war against their neighbors and made slaves of their defeated rivals is as clear and understandable as any other law of nature. The Khans of Mongolia conquered most of Eurasia and committed atrocities that rival anything that Hitler or Stalin committed. Empires in India, the Middle East and Meso-America conquered and enslaved their neighbors whenever the opportunity arose. The tribes and nations of Sub-Saharan Africa even in modern times have committed genocidal attacks on their enemies that have stunned outsiders by their cruelty. Man has been a terrifying enemy to his neighbors for as long as he has existed. In fact, it is ignored that the English were the ones who ended slavery inside their vast empire in the nineteenth century with the United States following their example shortly after. It was Europeans (the Swiss and the English and their descendants) who first resurrected democracy after a lapse of thousands of years since the end of the first attempts back in ancient Athens. And with respect to women’s rights, England and the United States, once again, were in the vanguard of that movement.
But none of this registers with Millennials. They’ve been proselytized and brow-beaten by their teachers from kindergarten to graduate school and beyond to acknowledge the hereditary guilt of belonging to a civilization that virtually alone has created the modern world that everyone lives in. And to atone for the “sins” of their ancestors they desire to hand over the country to anyone who desires to come here to live. They think it would be better if America belonged to the world. “After all,” they think, “we stole it from someone else, we should give it back.”
What they’re too blind to realize is that if they indeed gave it to the world, it soon wouldn’t be a place that the world would want to live in. It is true that many people come to America to get free stuff. They see a gravy train and figure on getting as much of what is being handed out for as long as it’s available. They typically send the money they get back home to their families and intend to return when it gets to be a big enough nest egg. But there have always been people who come to America because they’ve heard that things are done right here. If you live in a country where the local strongman can take your property or even abuse your family with impunity then it doesn’t matter if you are relatively well off. A lawless society is a violent and chaotic place where only the strongest survive and even they know a stronger man will eventually come along to supplant them. Whether it was German peasants fleeing religious wars or Southern Italians fleeing poverty and the cruel intimidation of the Mafia people came to the United States because for the most part the middle class here were able to negotiate a sane existence where their children could live a decent life and maybe even better themselves over time.
But as the older population knows, every time a new wave of immigrants arrives and crowds the slums of the old cities, it creates crime and poverty and resentment between the older inhabitants and the new immigrants. At that point, in the past, immigration is halted. Then it takes fifty years for the new immigrants to assimilate and blend into the American way of life. And normal life resumes for the bulk of the inhabitants.
But if the Millennials (and the Democrat leadership and the corporations who need cheap labor) have their way, then there will be no halt to the influx of immigrants. Eventually we will reach a tipping point where the new arrivals will swamp out the cultural Americans and it won’t be America anymore. Once enough people will sell their vote for some short-term economic benefit, all the things that made the United States unique, things like the Bill of Rights, will be legislated away and we will live in the same lawless jungle that all those who came here fled from.
It took almost two thousand years between Ancient Athens and Modern Europe for democracy to reappear. If it disappears here, it may take that long for it to reappear. We must do what we can to stop this stupid idea that everyone can move to America.
And it’s unnecessary. The whole world knows what a working civilization looks like. It was the civilization that flourished in Europe during the industrial revolution. It was when man used science and intelligence to improve the way he lived. This can be copied and adapted to the local conditions. It won’t be like America but it will be better than the tribal life that preceded modernity. We don’t need to let everyone come here. We don’t even have to enforce our standards on these more backward countries. But we can insist that if they want to have any interaction with us that they must maintain some reasonable standards of behavior to allow that interaction to be acceptable to us. We can make common cause with countries that have the same aspirations as us. Those that don’t we can ignore. But we don’t owe even friendly nations the right to flood our country and disrupt our way of life.
So, to hell with the Millennials and their idiot teachers. This is our way of life here and we don’t want to lose it.