Having just lived through a stolen presidential election I thought this was the perfect time to review Preston Sturges’ comical look at crooked politics.
The movie opens up in a bar in a Latin American country. A young American is getting drunk and becoming more and more depressed. He had to escape from the United States and leave his family behind because he was a bank teller who got caught stealing money. The bartender played by Brian Donlevy follows him into the bathroom just in time to stop him from shooting himself. The bartender tells him not to despair. He tells the young man that his case is minor compared to his own. Then he tells his story and the scene changes to the bartender’s story. We find out his name Dan McGinty.
When we first see him, he is a hobo in tattered clothes wandering the streets of some big eastern city, probably New York. It’s election day and a political hack (played by William Demerast) collars him and tells him that if he votes for the crooked mayor under an assumed name, he’ll get paid two bucks. When McGinty asks the fixer, what happens if he can vote twice the guy tells him he’ll get four bucks. So McGinty goes to every polling station and votes thirty-seven times. But the fixer doesn’t have enough money to pay McGinty off so he brings him down to headquarters to ask the “Boss” for the cash. The Boss, played hilariously with an absurd Russian accent by Akim Tamiroff, is so impressed by McGinty’s nerve that he takes him under his wing to make him a successful crook. First, he makes McGinty a collector for the protection racket that the Boss runs. When his verbal and pugilistic skills allow him to clean up even the most delinquent customers the Boss realizes that McGinty will rise very high in the Boss’s political machine. He graduates to squeezing all the city contractors for the kickbacks that the Boss gets for letting them skip the bidding process. The relationship between McGinty and the Boss is one of fratricidal familiarity. They are both berserk fighters who enjoy nothing better than brawling with each other at the drop of a hat. There are several brawls in the course of the movie.
Eventually the Boss decides that the old mayor is too weak and he decides that McGinty will be the new mayor. But before he can run, he has to get married. Apparently the newly enfranchised woman vote didn’t cotton to bachelor mayors. He and his secretary Catherine form a marriage of convenience. She is a divorcee with two kids and they both agree that a marriage in name only would suit them both. But as you can guess eventually, they both fall in love and ruin the whole thing. Catherine is at heart an idealist and she hopes that some day Dan can go straight and get out from under the Boss’s thumb.
Finally, the Boss decides to run McGinty for governor and he wins. Now McGinty decides he wants Catherine and the kids to respect him so he has it out with the Boss. And right in the governor’s office he and the Boss get into a colossal fist fight and then the Boss pulls a gun and tries to shoot McGinty for which he is hauled off to jail for attempted murder.
But the Boss gets his revenge and has McGinty arrested for being involved in a crooked contract back when he was mayor. Now the Boss and McGinty are in adjoining cells and they strike a deal and the Boss arranges for both of them to break out of jail and escape the country. McGinty just has enough time to call Catherine and tell her where there is a safety deposit box with enough money to take care of her and the kids for life.
In the next scene they’re back in the Latin American bar where McGinty is the bartender and the Boss is the owner. Just as he finishes the story and calms the young man down, he decides to make the cash register ring. This is supposed to tip off the Boss that McGinty is stealing from him and they get into one of their habitual fistfights. Obviously, the fight is the highlight of the day for both of these exiles.
Preston Sturges wrote and directed this comedy and like many of his films it has an originality sadly lacking in most movies. The characters of McGinty and the Boss are extremely vivid and despite their obvious criminality quite likeable. The rest of the cast are more than adequate and the dialog is quite good. Highly recommended.