When I was much younger, I remember wondering if there would ever be a time when the state of the art in “film” would allow a decent version of the Lord of the Rings to be made. When Ralph Bakshi’s cartoon over live action was made in 1978, I was quite surprised at how good it was. And I hoped that he would continue the project to finish the complete story. But he never did. Maybe he didn’t make enough money or maybe he got bored. And so, it would be another twenty years before anyone tried again.
Peter Jackson did a remarkable job both visually and artistically of capturing Tolkien’s story. And I think he proved that we have reached a point where regardless of the unreal or fantastic nature of the story CGI can produce a convincing visual representation of that story on the screen. And that was an important moment. For a fan of science fiction and fantasy this is the promised land.
And yet, what have we got now? For every film like Dune where the story faithfully reproduces a worthwhile piece of fiction, we get ten movies like “The Marvels” or “The Last Jedi” or “Madame Web” where the visuals are successful but the story and the acting are unwatchable.
Well, that’s reality. The cultural and societal standards are pretty awful so even if some interesting topic like the Second Age of Middle Earth (Rings of Power) or Harry Seldon’s Psychohistory (Foundation) are being filmed chances are that the result will be terrible.
But the only good thing I can say is that the potential exists for a rogue force like Elon Musk to come along and fund an independent studio to produce some exciting projects. So, eventually we will get good movies. Eventually the profit motive will succeed. Who knows we may be forced to watch Chinese or Hungarian movies in subtitles but it will come. So, patience, patience.
And what might make a good project? Well, based on what we know would sell, how about space opera that is a lot more interesting than the Star Wars universe? How about a project to film the Lensman series? A few updates to the technology might be needed and the chronology might need to be tweaked but then the story would be easily turned into a series of films. It has likeable heroes, awful villains, interesting aliens and plenty of space battles. And best of all, not a girl boss in sight. Just classic square-jawed heroes saving the day and rescuing the damsel in distress. I would guess that the Lensman saga would be easily as popular as Star Wars and in fact more so.
Now another popular film idea would be the Heinlein juveniles. There are several good candidates. As a first choice I’d go with, “Have Spacesuit Will Travel.” It has all the requisite ingredients for a good young adult movie; human interest, suspense, adventure, pathos, humor and the resolution of a coming-of-age story. As a second choice I’d recommend, “The Star Beast.”
It’s an interesting thing to reflect that a really satisfactory movie version of a Heinlein book has never been done. The only one he ever had a hand in was Destination Moon. And while technically there were interesting aspects to the production as a movie it was pretty cut and dry; more of a primer on rocket flight than work of fiction. In terms of popularity, I guess Starship Troopers is the best of those produced, even though the director made it in the spirit of a mockery of the underlying philosophy of the book. A faithful portrayal of Starship Troopers would be an amazing idea for a movie.
And rounding off my picks for Heinlein would be, “The Moon is a Harsh Mistress.” I think this story would make an excellent film too. I’d especially enjoy seeing the rail gun attack on Earth on the big screen. And I think the friendship between Manny and the artificial intelligence Mike would work great on the screen.
I’ll have to think of some other classic sf&f books that would make good movies. If you can think of any you’d like to see made, leave them in the comments.