In the Hollywood film, “The Bad and the Beautiful” there is a discussion between an actor named Gaucho and a bit-part actress on the make named Lila. Gaucho tells her that his producer friend Jonathan (Kirk Douglas’s character) is a great man. But world-weary Lila laughs and replies “There are no great men, buster, there’s only men.”
So, are there any great men? Were there ever any? Is a Caesar or a Napoleon great? Or were they just great generals. Was Einstein great or was he merely a genius? Was Socrates a great man or merely annoying? How about St Paul?
It seems to me that the definition of a great man is one who is both intelligent and moral. So, it’s not enough to be brilliant if the use of your intelligence is to do evil. And it’s not enough to be a saint if you cannot somehow use this moral sense to benefit humanity as a whole or at least a significant chunk of it.
Framed the way I have here it’s not that easy to pick out these exceptional beings. I guess religious leaders like Jesus, Buddha, Moses stand out. They’ve had an outsized impact on the world. They understood the problem of living in the world of men. It’s so very hard to know what is the right thing to do in the multitude of decisions we make as we negotiate the confusing and frightening human world. How often we choose the easier thing instead of the “right” choice. We compromise our morals and standards to avoid pain or discomfort or even embarrassment. How much more will a leader compromise because the stakes are just so incredibly high.
I guess the only leader that comes to mind is Marcus Aurelius; the philosopher king. Not that he was perfect or that none of his philosophy was misguided. But without a doubt he was intelligent and he used his powerful office to provide the best government he could to the millions who lived within the Roman empire in the second century AD. Maybe this is an example of a great man.
So which Americans were great? Washington, Jefferson? Maybe. In the last one hundred and fifty years I don’t think there’s been much greatness. FDR had a large impact on the country but I don’t think he was wise. And so many of our recent presidents are neither moral nor wise. Some were truly awful, like Bill Clinton, Barack Obama and especially Joe Biden.
So where does that leave Donald Trump? Well, morality is not his forte. His private life is a mess. You need look no further than the “Stormy Daniels” episode to see that he does not restrain his baser nature at all. Then again do any of the wealthy ever do better? As for intelligence, he’s not a stupid man. He is an ambitious businessman who knows how to market himself. Is he wise? Well, he’s no philosopher king. But I think he does feel affection for his countrymen. I think he does want to make America a better place and make life better for Americans.
So, let’s just say that if he succeeds, Donald Trump will perform a truly great service for the United States of America. He will save it from the forces that are currently destroying it. He can vanquish the managerial bureaucracy that rules over us and is leeching away our strength and vitality. He will succeed where a century of American presidents has failed to save their country. That would be great.



