In the first part of this essay, I stated that the Greeks and Romans utterly failed in their attempt at democratic or even representative government. And that is demonstrably true. Athens lasted less than a lifetime as a democracy and Rome was never anything but an oligarchy masquerading as a popular government. Even when the emperor was the supreme power in the state somehow the plutocrats still got all the laws they needed to bleed the poor dry and prevent any least benefit for the people who made up the bulk of the empire. So, yeah, Rome was a slave camp for everyone but the rich.
But how about us? Have we improved on what the ancients had? Well, we at least have eliminated slavery. That is one absolute advantage. And theoretically we have representative government. In some sense I have a chance of someone who thinks the way I do writing the laws and enforcing them. Okay, there’s something like that going on. After all, look, Donald Trump is president for the second time. He’s even been able to eject large numbers of Deep State ringers out of the federal government. And he’s even been able to primary Republicans who vote against the reforms he’s pushing. He has made some headway toward populist outcomes to some of the worst situations we live under. He has been attempting to reverse unconstitutional laws and rulings like anti-white and anti-male discrimination.
But what we’re seeing is only the first steps. And this is Trump’s last term. Will more progress be made. After all, even under the Roman Republic there were attempted reforms. Tiberius Gracchus was a famous example. He attempted to stop the patricians from robbing poor farmers of their land every time they were forced to fight in a war. While they were in the army their families got into debt just to feed themselves and when they got home the government refused to forgive these debts in gratitude for their military service and these families ended up losing their farms to the greedy moneylenders who added these acres to their already obscenely large landholdings. Gracchus attempted to bring these protections to a vote and was murdered by a mob for his trouble. Interestingly Trump has already dodged two assassins already. When J. D. Vance and the other republicans run for president in 2028, I hope their secret service protection is a lot better than what candidate Trump had in 2024.
So, yes, we have improved somewhat on the fairness of the government we have over the ancients. But many of the same problems haunt us. Graft, influence peddling, complete indifference for the working and middle classes and a bloated bureaucracy that swallows up enormous resources that should go to useful government projects like infrastructure and industrial planning that make it possible for businesses to expand and hire more people.
In the next part I want to look at whether the current method we use for selecting leaders which at least nominally is supposed to be based on Greek and Roman models is really the best method or whether some other structure would be better.
