How many times have pundits (including my humble self) declared that we are already irrevocably tobogganing down the slope toward the decline and fall of the American Empire? Probably too many to count. And it’s not as if there isn’t a lot of dysfunction everywhere you look. I won’t go through the litany. It’s almost endless but all we have to mention to provide an undeniable example of societal rot and insanity is the spectacle of the American Medical Association embracing “gender affirming” treatments for minors including hormone therapies, mastectomies, hysterectomies and castration.
But what if things are about to improve? Suppose the Trump administration is followed by the Vance administration and during this reprieve from leftist lunacy the country gets its financial health back to a greater extent. Let’s go with that scenario. People have enough money to buy houses again and raise kids and plan for the future. What would that look like? Of course, I have no way of actually knowing but let’s play the game and throw out some ideas and see if it leads us somewhere.
First off, I think it’s important to say what it won’t look like. It’s not going to look like America in the 1950s or even the 1980s or 1990s. The adults and children today; the millennials and the zoomers are very different from my parents’ generation and mine. They’ve been propagandized in school and through social media to despise the world from those olden times. They’re ashamed of their parents and grandparents and want to conform to the norms they’ve been taught.
Some of this can be seen in the situation playing out in New York City’s mayoral race. The last two mayors have been liberal Democrats and under their administrations all the improvements in quality of life and safety gained during Republican mayors have been lost and the city is on the verge of collapsing into chaos. So, what do the people there want in the next mayor? A communist! Now this is just an example. There are others. A similar radical is running for mayor of Minneapolis. So, there is no lack of evidence that the millennials believe insane things. Now it is true that there is precedent for people who believe these things being gob-smacked by reality and changing their minds. Maybe that’s what we’re going to see. It happened to the baby boomers in the nineteen seventies and eighties. Maybe it’ll happen again.
But regardless, things will be very different. I believe there has been a breach between the older America and what will follow. It will not be the monolithic culture. It will be several, or possibly many separate cultures. Identity groups have been spawned and they will not disappear. Ethnic and locality identities will develop and they will complicate social cohesion. Hollywood and other purveyors of cultural content won’t be able to put out one product that resonates with everyone. We already see that. The multicultural experiment with superhero movies and other content have fizzled because people recognize they’re being handed a narrative to cheer for someone else’s team. How many teenage boys want a female superhero beating up on much larger men as the template for the movies they are being handed. They just stay home and play video games that allow them to control the narrative.
So, America might recover and even thrive. But it will take generations for it to coalesce into a common identity. In the meantime, we and our descendants will have to look out for our own interests, forming alliances and voting blocks where advantage exists. There may even be a shining city on a hill. But on the next hill may be a hellhole. And that’s just the way it’ll have to be.